Peer Review

My work as a reviewer of manuscripts has increased recently. I think word got around that while I remain committed to quality when it comes to scholarly / scientific work, I don’t find it necessary to be cruel in conveying what needs to get done. That is, I write reviews like I would comments on a student paper — be it a freshman or a dissertator — constructively.

Sadly, this is not a universal practice, and so this cartoon rings true:

Peer Review

(Visited 11 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply